Every manifesto promise made by every States of Guernsey deputy, checked against how they actually voted. Ranked by who keeps their word — not who talks the most.
The Scorecard logs every public manifesto commitment made by a States deputy, then links it to the closest matching vote in the Assembly. Each link is graded for how directly it bears on the promise — so a loosely related vote can't unfairly swing someone's record either way. Deputies are ranked by kept-rate: the share of their vote-linked promises they've actually kept.
Ranking is by kept-rate, not raw promises kept — a deputy with four firm commitments kept can't be beaten by one who made eighty vague ones. A floor of five vote-linked promises applies before anyone is ranked at all.
Presidents carry the most influence over policy — and the most promises to answer for. Their kept-rates split sharply.
Manifesto commitments and public pledges are logged per deputy as individual, dated promises — 504 in total across all 38 deputies.
Each promise is checked against the Assembly's voting record for a matching debate. 272 of 504 have been linked to date; the rest await a relevant vote.
Every match is graded high, medium or low for how directly it bears on the promise. Only high and medium links count toward a verdict — low-relevance links are shown for context on a deputy's page but don't move their score.
Deputies need at least five scored promises before they're ranked at all — thinner records sit below an "insufficient record" divider rather than gaming the top or bottom of the table on a single vote.
The full leaderboard, methodology and individual deputy pages are live now.
View the Scorecard →guernsey.bridgeheadcommunications.com/rankings · methodology at /methodology