Isle of Man House of Keys Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE HOUSE OF KEYS

PRE-LAUNCH FEEDBACK PHASE — Public launch: Monday, 19 October 2026
← All members

Andrew Smith

Member of the House of Keys for Garff · Independent

Not in the 2026 to 2031 House · seat shown is from the 2021 to 2026 House

Manifesto · 2021 to 2026 House

The 2021 manifestos are not archived.


n/a

Promises catalogued

240

Recorded divisions voted in

Voted For in 183 divisions and Against in 57 during the 2021 to 2026 House. The Keys prints only who voted, so this says nothing about attendance.

Manifesto

Manifesto promises, 2021 to 2026 House

Grouped by policy area. Each promise is quoted exactly as it appears in the manifesto, with a one-line summary written by us (not the member) and a link to the source. A promise is tested once a recorded division bears on it; until then it is marked as having no recorded vote yet, not scored.

The 2021 manifestos are not archived, so no promises are catalogued for this term. Its recorded divisions are listed below.

Voting record

Recent recorded votes

This member's most recent divisions in the House of Keys, newest first, whether or not they relate to a manifesto promise. The Keys prints only the names of those who voted, so a division a member is missing from says nothing about why.

Voting record · 2021 to 2026 House

Every recorded division

Newest first. Each row links to the Hansard or Votes and Proceedings document the names were read from. Divisions whose printed names do not add up to the Speaker's declared tally are left out.

DateItem before the HouseVotedResult
30 June 2026Nicotine Products Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
30 June 2026Nicotine Products Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
9 June 2026Motion sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
9 June 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 5
9 June 2026Questions sourceForCarried, 18 to 2
26 May 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 11
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 11 to 12
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 7 to 16
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
12 May 2026Financial Services (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
12 May 2026Financial Services (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 13 to 10
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 6
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 6
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 19 to 4
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 20 to 3
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 8
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 7 to 16
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 12
5 May 2026Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
28 April 2026Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 19 to 1
28 April 2026Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 2
28 April 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
24 March 2026Safe Access Zones and Protected Public Places Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
24 March 2026That Standing Order 4.6 be suspended to permit the Second Reading of the Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 to be taken at this sitting. sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
24 March 2026That Standing Order 4.6 be suspended to permit the Second Reading of the Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 to be taken at this sitting. sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
3 March 2026Gas (Economic Regulation) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
24 February 2026Gas (Economic Regulation) Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 2 to 22
24 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 5
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstCarried, 12 to 8
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 5
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 8
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForLost, 4 to 17
10 February 2026Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 4
3 February 2026Justice and Home Affairs (Reform and Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Justice and Home Affairs (Reform and Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 22 to 1
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 21 to 2
27 January 2026That the House assigns the Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 to Mr Crookall, who shall assume the role of member in charge for the remaining stages of the Bill. sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 18 to 6
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 13
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 13
27 January 2026That the Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Council on the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 [PP 2025/0127] be received. sourceForCarried, 23 to 1
27 January 2026That the Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Council on the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 [PP 2025/0127] be received. sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
27 January 2026That under Standing Orders 2.1(3) and 3.11(2) leave of the House be given to item sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 4
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 12
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 12 to 8
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 13 to 7
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 13
13 January 2026Public Records (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForLost, 8 to 12
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 14 to 6
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
13 January 2026Questions sourceForCarried, 13 to 7
16 December 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
16 December 2025Public Records (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
16 December 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
2 December 2025Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
2 December 2025Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
2 December 2025Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 21 to 3
2 December 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
25 November 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 12 to 9
4 November 2025City of Douglas Bill 2025 Dr Haywood Bill read the second time. sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
4 November 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
28 October 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
28 October 2025Motion sourceForLost, 9 to 14
28 October 2025Leave to introduce sourceForCarried, 21 to 2
28 October 2025Motion sourceForLost, 9 to 14
28 October 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
24 June 2025Motion sourceForLost, 6 to 17
24 June 2025Motion sourceForLost, 5 to 18
24 June 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 14 to 9
24 June 2025Questions sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
10 June 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
13 May 2025Questions (resumed) sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
13 May 2025Questions (resumed) sourceForLost, 9 to 14
13 May 2025Reproductive Rights Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
13 May 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
13 May 2025Questions sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 16
8 April 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
1 April 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 1
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 5
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForLost, 5 to 18
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
25 February 2025Questions sourceForLost, 8 to 15
11 February 2025Motion sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
11 February 2025Statute Law Revision (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) Mr Ashford Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 17
11 February 2025Statute Law Revision (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) Mr Ashford Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 18
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForLost, 3 to 21
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForLost, 5 to 19
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForCarried, 17 to 3
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForLost, 7 to 13
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForCarried, 16 to 3
28 January 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
17 December 2024Income Tax Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
17 December 2024Safe Access Zones and Protected Public Places Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
17 December 2024Questions sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 15
17 December 2024Questions sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 15
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 14 to 8
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 12
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 17
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 19 to 3
26 November 2024Charities Registration and Regulation (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 18 to 4
26 November 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
12 November 2024Charities Registration and Regulation (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
5 November 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
29 October 2024Motion of No Confidence sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 18
22 October 2024Questions sourceForLost, 8 to 12
23 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 8
23 July 2024Questions sourceForLost, 7 to 17
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 8
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 8
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 12
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Private Member’s Bill to amend the meaning of tobacco products for the purposes of the Children and Young Person’s Act 1966 and sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Private Member’s Bill to amend the meaning of tobacco products for the purposes of the Children and Young Person’s Act 1966 and sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Bill to make provision about the purpose of referenda; donations, finances and campaigns in connection with referenda; the sourceForCarried, 13 to 10
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 13
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 8
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForLost, 9 to 15
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForLost, 4 to 20
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForLost, 10 to 14
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForLost, 9 to 15
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForLost, 11 to 12
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 12
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
25 June 2024Public Sector Payments Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 17
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 14
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 15
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
25 June 2024Town and Country Planning (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 5 to 18
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 8
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 15
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 4 to 20
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 11 to 12
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 8
25 June 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForLost, 7 to 16
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForLost, 9 to 14
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
11 June 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 21 to 2
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 9 to 15
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 18 to 6
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 8 to 16
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 14
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 14
7 May 2024Leave to Introduce sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
7 May 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 9
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 1 to 23
7 May 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
30 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 10
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 12 to 12
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 10
26 March 2024Health Services Consultative Committee sourceForLost, 7 to 15
26 March 2024Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 9
26 March 2024Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 9
5 March 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 1
23 January 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceForLost, 11 to 13
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceForLost, 11 to 13
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceAgainstLost, 3 to 19
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
5 December 2023Bill for Second Reading sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
7 November 2023Bishop’s vote sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 11
7 November 2023Assisted Dying Bill: reference to Committee sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
7 November 2023Assisted Dying Bill: reference to Committee sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 14
31 October 2023Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 7
13 June 2023Bills for First Reading sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
14 March 2023Standing Orders Committee of the House of Keys sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
24 May 2022Leave to Introduce sourceAgainstCarried, 22 to 2
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
3 May 2022Bills for First Reading sourceForCarried, 21 to 3
8 February 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceAgainstCarried, 20 to 3
8 February 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 6
19 October 2021NOMINATION OF CHIEF MINISTER sourceForCarried, 21 to 3

How this record is built, and what it leaves out, is on the methodology page.