Guernsey · Promises vs votes
Would I Lie to You? · Guernsey EditionEvery promise States Deputies made in their 2025 election manifestos, set against how they have actually voted in the States of Deliberation. Kept, broken, or somewhere in between, with the recorded votes to prove it. Where no recorded vote bears on a promise, we assess delivery against the public record. How this works.
Deputies tracked
39
Committee leadership (pilot)
Manifesto promises
511
Extracted from 2025 manifestos
Recorded votes
204
States of Deliberation, this term
Tied to a vote
273 / 511
53% map to a recorded vote
Overall
Across every tracked deputy. A promise is 'kept' when the deputy voted to deliver it on every bearing recorded vote, 'broken' when they voted against, 'mixed' when both, 'abstained' when they sat the relevant votes out. The rest have no bearing recorded vote yet.
By deputy
Ranked by kept-rate, the share of their voted-on promises each deputy kept, among those with enough of a voting record to rank; thinner records follow. Click any deputy for their promise-by-promise record with the votes behind each verdict.
20 kept · 95% of voted-on promises
