Isle of Man House of Keys Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE HOUSE OF KEYS

← All members

Sarah Maltby

Member of the House of Keys for Douglas South · Manx Labour Party

Elected on 24 September 2026 with 1,245 votes, first of five candidates.

Sarah Maltby
Photo: Tynwald

Sarah Maltby was born in Douglas and educated at Ballakermeen High School and the University of Chester, where she studied counselling with communication studies. Before entering politics she worked in home care and support roles and, from 2007 to 2021, as a senior education support officer in the learning support department at Ballakermeen High School. She was first elected for Douglas South in 2021 and was a political member of the Treasury's social security division (2021-2024) and of the Department for Enterprise with responsibility for Visit Isle of Man and motorsport (2024-2026). She has been a Manx Labour Party member since 2011, its deputy leader since 2021 and its chair since 2024.

Manifesto · 2026 to 2031 House

The 22 promises below are quoted from this document.

Read the manifesto →Archived copy →

Sources and contact


22

Promises catalogued

0

Recorded divisions voted in

The 2026 to 2031 House has not yet recorded any divisions.

Manifesto

Manifesto promises, 2026 to 2031 House

Grouped by policy area. Each promise is quoted exactly as it appears in the manifesto, with a one-line summary written by us (not the member) and a link to the source. A promise is tested once a recorded division bears on it; until then it is marked as having no recorded vote yet, not scored.

Housing and planning

2 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Increase affordable, social and 'last time' housing supply.”

    Our summaryCandidate will work to increase the supply of affordable, social and 'last time' housing.

    Housing

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “■ Tasking Treasury to reinvest commuted sums ■ Champion brownfield first development and stronger biodiversity protections ■ Ensure government investment delivers long-term value for taxpayers ■ Encourage responsible development that provides for greater protection for the environment”

    Our summaryCandidate will push Treasury to reinvest commuted sums into affordable housing and champion brownfield-first development.

    HousingEnvironment and climatePlanning and development

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Health and social care

2 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Call for legislative changes to protect against financial ruin and improve fairness if residential or nursing care is required.”

    Our summaryCandidate will call for legislation to protect individuals from financial ruin when residential or nursing care is needed.

    Health and careOlder people

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I will continue pressing for urgent reform and a system built on fairness, respect and compassion.”

    Our summaryCandidate will continue pressing for urgent reform of the care funding system.

    Health and careOlder people

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Education and families

2 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Expand early intervention, reduce gaps in attainment and provision and strengthen vocational pathways.”

    Our summaryCandidate will expand early intervention in education and strengthen vocational pathways.

    Education

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Continue improving accessibility and inclusive childcare support.”

    Our summaryCandidate will continue to improve accessibility and inclusive childcare support.

    Children and familiesHealth and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Economy, tax and cost of living

5 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “■ Secure a fairer funding arrangement for the Manx National Heritage Trust ■ Champion investment in the arts to promote wellbeing and social prescribing opportunities”

    Our summaryCandidate will seek fairer funding for Manx National Heritage Trust and champion arts investment for wellbeing.

    Tourism and heritageHealth and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Continue diversifying the economy and supporting local businesses.”

    Our summaryCandidate will continue to support economic diversification and local businesses.

    Economy and business

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Continue pushing for stronger consumer protections and accessible services.”

    Our summaryCandidate will push for stronger consumer protections and more accessible services.

    Economy and businessGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “■ Improve connectivity to encourage repeat visits and longer stays ■ Promote the Island as a sustainable destination for responsible travellers ■ Support off-season events”

    Our summaryCandidate will work to improve connectivity, promote sustainable tourism, and support off-season events.

    Tourism and heritageInfrastructure and transport

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I remain committed to building the political consensus needed to deliver a fairer and more transparent property rating system that reflects modern realities.”

    Our summaryCandidate will work to build consensus for reform of the Island's outdated property rating system.

    Tax and public financesGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Infrastructure, energy and environment

5 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “My priority is to call on Government to complete the necessary legislation so this commitment can be fully implemented, giving developers greater certainty and clearer expectations.”

    Our summaryCandidate will call on Government to complete legislation to implement the Biodiversity Net Gain Policy.

    Environment and climatePlanning and development

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Develop balanced renewable energy strategy with environmental safeguards.”

    Our summaryCandidate will work to develop a balanced renewable energy strategy with environmental protections.

    Energy and utilitiesEnvironment and climate

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Secure recurring funding to maintain footpaths and public infrastructure.”

    Our summaryCandidate will seek to secure recurring funding for footpath and public infrastructure maintenance.

    Infrastructure and transportEnvironment and climate

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “■ Secure the uplift for the Public Rights of Way Maintenance budget ■ Strengthen partnerships with community volunteer groups focused on conservation of the Island's unique and natural beauty”

    Our summaryCandidate will seek a budget uplift for Public Rights of Way maintenance and strengthen conservation partnerships.

    Environment and climateInfrastructure and transport

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I will continue to advocate for improved consultation with residents, better services and initiatives such as free bus travel for specific purposes, which could benefit both the local economy and the environment.”

    Our summaryCandidate will advocate for improved bus consultation, better services, and free bus travel for specific purposes.

    Infrastructure and transportLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Governance and public services

6 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetaspirational

    In the manifesto

    “A 'one-stop' digital settlement portal would help new arrivals access information on schools, childcare, healthcare and community services, while also making clear what support and services may not be immediately available to them.”

    Our summaryCandidate will support creation of a one-stop digital settlement portal for new arrivals to the Island.

    Population and migrationDigital and connectivity

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I support reforms that simplify the work permit process for employers while introducing clearer requirements and registration processes for new arrivals. Our work permit system must be responsive to the Island's economic needs by helping employers address genuine skills shortages, while protecting opportunities for Isle of Man residents.”

    Our summaryCandidate will support work permit reform to simplify processes for employers while protecting local workers.

    Population and migrationEconomy and business

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “A key priority remains reinstating the Pulrose Football Club changing rooms. I have worked closely with the committee, providing practical support and guidance on securing funding through the Manx Lottery Trust to help bring the facility back into use.”

    Our summaryCandidate will continue pursuing reinstatement of Pulrose Football Club changing rooms via Manx Lottery Trust funding.

    Local and constituencyInfrastructure and transport

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Continue strong representation and work to improve government communication and transparency.”

    Our summaryCandidate will continue constituency representation and push to improve government communication and transparency.

    Governance and constitutionLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Streamline duplication within the Government workforce, modernise systems and reinvest savings to strengthen frontline services”

    Our summaryCandidate will streamline government workforce duplication, modernise systems, and reinvest savings into frontline services.

    Public sector reformTax and public finances

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetconditional

    In the manifesto

    “If re-elected, I will ensure the findings of this review are debated in Tynwald and that meaningful reforms are implemented where necessary.”

    Our summaryCandidate will ensure the Sexual Offences Act review findings are debated in Tynwald and meaningful reforms implemented.

    Justice and home affairsGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2026 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Background

Career in Tynwald

As listed on the official Tynwald profile, retrieved on 6 October 2026, quoted as published. Tynwald writes these entries; we have not added to them.

  • Member of the House of Keys 2026-date.
  • Political member for the Department for Enterprise with delegation for the Visit IOM agency and Motorsport 2024-2026.
  • Political member for the Department of Education, Sport and Culture 2024-2026.
  • Political Trustee of the Manx Lottery Trust 2021- 2026.
  • Political Trustee for Manx National Heritage 2025-2026.
  • Chair of the Isle of Man Arts Council 2024-2026.
  • Member on the Skills Board 2024- 2026.
  • Member on the Destination First Board 2024- 2026.
  • Member of the Tynwald Management Committee 2021-2026.
  • Member of the Select Committee on Poverty 2021-2026.
  • Member of the CPA Isle of Man Branch Executive Committee 2021-2026.
  • Committees of Tynwald: Chair of the Select Committee of Tynwald on Public Footpaths, Bridleways and Green Lanes (Petition for Redress) 2021-2022; Member of the Select Committee of Tynwald to Appoint an Independent Review of the Management of the Ranson Case 2023-2024.
  • Political Member for the Department of: Treasury (Social Security Division) 2021-2024.
  • Member of the Ukraine Support Advisory Group March 2021-2023
  • Chair of the Isle of Man Constabulary Inclusion and Scrutiny Group April 2021-2024
  • First elected as Member of the House of Keys 2021; re-elected in 2026.

Source: tynwald.org.im

Voting record

Recent recorded votes

This member's most recent divisions in the House of Keys, newest first, whether or not they relate to a manifesto promise. The Keys prints only the names of those who voted, so a division a member is missing from says nothing about why.

Manifesto · Closed term

Manifesto promises, 2021 to 2026 House

Member of the House of Keys for Douglas South · Manx Labour Party. This term has closed: it is shown here as this member's earlier record, not the live one.

26

Promises catalogued

226

Divisions voted in

145

Voted For

81

Voted Against

Housing and planning

3 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “More Local Authority housing to meet the actual needs of the population should be provided. Those who have brought up families and no longer need a large house could be assisted into smaller more appropriate bungalows, flats or sheltered accommodation. A 'not for profit' housing association could cooperate with Local Authorities to ensure such provision.”

    Our summarySupport provision of more Local Authority housing and a not-for-profit housing association to assist downsizing residents.

    HousingOlder people

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “There has been ongoing discussion about the need for an all island housing policy over the past 5 Years at least. It is essential we translate talk into action.”

    Our summaryPush for implementation of a national all-island housing policy.

    HousingPlanning and development

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “I would suggest the re establishment of Tenants associations to facilitate this.”

    Our summaryAdvocate for the re-establishment of tenants' associations in Local Authority housing.

    HousingLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Health and social care

6 promises

2linked divisions

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Wherever this is caused by Government action, or inaction, it would be my intention to seek to make real progress towards making our lovely Island a more equal place to live and work. Particular examples drawn to my attention relate to people with disabilities, the LGBTQ+ community and by far the most problematic is the fall out of the covid 19 lockdowns.”

    Our summarySeek to advance equality for people with disabilities, the LGBTQ+ community and those affected by COVID-19 lockdowns.

    Social security and benefitsHealth and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “How can it be acceptable that on our Island there remains a need for food banks and we have a homeless persons situation? We still have no legislation to cover the latter and our objective must be to raise living standards to eliminate the need for the former.”

    Our summaryPush for homelessness legislation and measures to raise living standards and reduce reliance on food banks.

    Social security and benefitsHousing

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I am very supportive of older people remaining in their own homes with assistance where required to facilitate this but again such provision needs adequate funding and I would be a supporter of its roll out.”

    Our summarySupport adequate funding and roll-out of home assistance services to enable older people to remain in their own homes.

    Older peopleHealth and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “The pandemic has worsened the position in a number of medical waiting lists. Health is a top priority and we must use every effort to ensure we reverse this situation. All our NHS staff have performed with distinction and it is important we retain and further recruit the skills needed.”

    Our summaryWork to reverse pandemic-related medical waiting list backlogs and support NHS staff retention and recruitment.

    Health and carePublic sector reform

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    2 linked divisions · how the member voted
    • 28 April 2026 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      National Health Service Reform Bill 2026

      The question as printed: “I put the question that the National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 be read for a second time.”

      Voted AgainstContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was that the National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 be read a second time; voting for advances reform of NHS structures which bears on supporting NHS staff and services, though does not directly address waiting list backlogs.

      ReviewThe promise concerns reversing waiting list backlogs and supporting NHS staff retention and recruitment, while the question was whether to give a second reading to a structural reform Bill about statutory roles and accountability frameworks, and voting against it could reflect concerns about the Bill's detail or approach rather than opposition to NHS improvement as such.

    • 9 June 2026 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      National Health Service Reform Bill 2026

      The question as printed: “I put the question that the National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 be read for a third time.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was that the National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 be read for a third time; voting for advances NHS reform legislation which bears on supporting NHS services and accountability.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I would make it my mission with my professional training to continue to support families in need of help and do everything within my power to ensure the system is properly resourced and that waiting times are significantly reduced as a result.”

    Our summaryWork to ensure mental health services are properly resourced and waiting times significantly reduced.

    Health and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Despite promises by the outgoing Government the unfairness in the system of care and nursing home provision have still not been alleviated. This must be a top priority for the incoming administration.”

    Our summaryMake reform of unfair care and nursing home provision a top priority for the new administration.

    Health and careOlder people

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Education and families

2 promises

1linked division

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I would like to see a more holistic approach to education where the measure of success is not always academically driven. Vocational studies, work and skills placements, a more comprehensive transition between key stages would all help to ensure some students are not left behind.”

    Our summaryAdvocate for a more holistic education approach including vocational studies and improved key stage transitions.

    Education

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    1 linked division · how the member voted
    • 2 December 2025 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      Education (Amendment) Bill 2025

      The question as printed: “I put the question that the Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 be read for a second time. Those in favour, please say aye; against, no.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was whether the Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 be read a second time, a Bill described as 'a comprehensive package of reforms designed to strengthen our education system', and voting For advances a more holistic education approach as promised.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “If elected it will be my duty to push for a fairer, workable deal.”

    Our summaryPush for a fairer deal on maternity/paternity, pre-school provision and before/after school care to attract young professionals.

    Children and familiesHealth and care

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Economy, tax and cost of living

2 promises

No recorded House of Keys division bears on this area yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Despite promises at Ministerial level by the outgoing administration we are still no nearer to a fairer rating system. It is right that island wide facilities such as the Villa Marina are funded on an all island basis.”

    Our summaryPush for a fairer island-wide rating system with island-wide facilities funded at the national level.

    Tax and public financesLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “I would propose the reintroduction of this overseeing body for important and necessary capital project schemes.”

    Our summaryPropose reintroduction of a Capital Projects oversight team in Treasury to manage major public spending schemes.

    Tax and public financesGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Infrastructure, energy and environment

5 promises

1linked division

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I would wish to open dialogue with them in relation to improving existing legislation to facilitate a more successful outcome.”

    Our summarySeek to improve legislation on litter, fly-tipping and anti-social behaviour through dialogue with Local Authorities.

    Environment and climateLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “We still have no clean air act on our Island and the treatment of sewerage is still unfinished. Both initiatives would enhance our Unesco biosphere status.”

    Our summaryPursue a Clean Air Act and completion of sewerage treatment infrastructure for the Isle of Man.

    Environment and climateEnergy and utilities

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I would call for much improved consultation with the public in advance to ensure they are not detrimentally effected and having to seek changes after the event.”

    Our summaryCall for improved advance public consultation on changes to bus routes and transport services.

    Infrastructure and transportGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I will continue to support and examine future schemes to ensure all road users are being treated fairly and that safety and practicalities are paramount over the aesthetics.”

    Our summarySupport and examine active travel and road schemes to ensure fairness and safety for all road users.

    Infrastructure and transportEnvironment and climate

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    1 linked division · how the member voted
    • 24 June 2025 · Lost · Votes and Proceedings

      Motion

      The question as printed: “Those in favour of the amendment, please say aye; against, no. The noes have it. Division called.”

      Voted AgainstContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe amendment proposed suspending the 20mph rollout and requiring further consultation and Tynwald approval before traffic orders, which would delay a road scheme affecting road users; voting Against the amendment (keeping the 20mph rollout proceeding) more directly advances supporting active travel and road safety schemes, though the connection is indirect.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “I would also propose a trial scheme of free public transport over a number of weekends for example which would have financial benefits for the local economy as well as the environment and could lead to further initiatives.”

    Our summaryPropose a trial scheme of free public transport over selected weekends to benefit the economy and environment.

    Infrastructure and transportEnvironment and climate

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Governance and public services

8 promises

4linked divisions

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “A Tynwald Auditor General, just as in other administrations would also be in a position to oversee financial costs in all areas of Government expenditure and potentially be self financing as a result.”

    Our summaryAdvocate for the creation of a Tynwald Auditor General to oversee all areas of Government expenditure.

    Governance and constitutionTax and public finances

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Government has backed off from this over successive administrations and it is time to revisit with devolving real powers at a local level leaving Tynwald to tackle the big issues facing our Island in the years ahead.”

    Our summarySupport Local Authority reform through amalgamation, shared services and devolution of real powers to local level.

    Governance and constitutionPublic sector reform

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    4 linked divisions · how the member voted
    • 28 January 2025 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part.

      The question as printed: “I put the question that new clause 1, which is amendment 1 on the Order Paper, be approved. Those in favour, please say aye; against, no.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was whether to approve a new clause to the Local Government (Amendment) Bill enabling minimum standards for local authority services, which bears on local authority reform and devolution of powers to local level, so voting For advances the promise.

    • 28 January 2025 · Lost · Votes and Proceedings

      Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part.

      The question as printed: “I put the question that amendment 2, which is new clause 2 in principle, be approved.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was whether to approve new clause 2 creating a statutory framework enabling local authorities to do their job with proper sanctions, which bears on devolving real powers to local level; voting For would advance that framework.

    • 11 February 2025 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes)

      The question as printed: “I put the question then that new clause 1, as amended, stands part of the Bill. Those in favour, please say aye; against, no.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was whether new clause 1, as amended, stands part of the Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023, and voting For advances local government reform as promised.

    • 28 April 2026 · Carried · Votes and Proceedings

      Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023

      The question as printed: “I put the question as at Item 4.1(b) on the Order Paper. Those in favour, please say aye; against, no.”

      Voted ForContext only: not counted towards the verdict.

      Why linkedThe question was that the House agree with the Council's amendments to the Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023; voting for advances Local Authority reform legislation which bears directly on the promise to support Local Authority reform.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “My preference would be for any necessary regulation to be Independent of any direct or indirect influence, perceived or otherwise, by Government. An Office of Fair Trading with enhanced authority and with an independent chair rather than a Government appointed Tynwald member would provide more confidence in the process for consumers.”

    Our summaryAdvocate for an independent Office of Fair Trading with enhanced authority and an independent chair.

    Governance and constitutionEconomy and business

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “I will raise the importance of putting in place a specific Isle of Man Animal Welfare act for the new administration as a top priority. I also believe the cruelty to animals legislation should be strengthened.”

    Our summaryRaise introduction of an Isle of Man Animal Welfare Act and strengthen cruelty to animals legislation as a top priority.

    Justice and home affairsGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “It was also mentioned that a regular newsletter and 'drop in' sessions with your MHK representatives would be welcomed.”

    Our summaryProvide regular newsletters and drop-in sessions to improve communication with constituents.

    Local and constituencyGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetspecific

    In the manifesto

    “I also believe that the police complaints system should revert to being undertaken by an independent person rather than being resolved internally.”

    Our summaryPush for police complaints to be handled by an independent person rather than resolved internally.

    Justice and home affairsGovernance and constitution

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “I would seek to prioritise safety within our estates with improved community policing, ensuring sensible traffic speed limits are adhered to, also on occasions shutting off areas in order for safe play for families.”

    Our summaryPrioritise community safety through improved policing, traffic speed enforcement and family-friendly play areas.

    Justice and home affairsLocal and constituency

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

  • No recorded vote yetdirectional

    In the manifesto

    “Community hubs and social spaces for young families, older people and educational workshops must be supported as part of our social responsibilities. Areas such as the Douglas Family Library shouldn't heavily rely on the change accumulated from the 'back of the sofa'.”

    Our summarySupport proper funding for community hubs, social spaces and facilities such as the Douglas Family Library.

    Local and constituencyChildren and families

    Source: Sarah Maltby, 2021 election manifesto

    No recorded division bears on this promise yet.

Voting record · 2021 to 2026 House

Every recorded division

Newest first. Each row links to the Hansard or Votes and Proceedings document the names were read from. Divisions whose printed names do not add up to the Speaker's declared tally are left out.

DateItem before the HouseVotedResult
30 June 2026Nicotine Products Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
30 June 2026Nicotine Products Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
9 June 2026Motion sourceForCarried, 22 to 0
9 June 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 16 to 5
9 June 2026Questions sourceForCarried, 18 to 2
26 May 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForLost, 11 to 11
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 9 to 14
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 11 to 12
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceForLost, 10 to 13
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
26 May 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
12 May 2026Financial Services (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
12 May 2026Financial Services (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026 sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 10
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
5 May 2026Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 12
5 May 2026Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
28 April 2026Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 19 to 1
28 April 2026Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 2
28 April 2026National Health Service Reform Bill 2026 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 5
24 March 2026Safe Access Zones and Protected Public Places Bill 2024 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 6
24 March 2026That Standing Order 4.6 be suspended to permit the Second Reading of the Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 to be taken at this sitting. sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
24 March 2026That Standing Order 4.6 be suspended to permit the Second Reading of the Retirement Benefits Schemes (Amendment) Bill 2026 to be taken at this sitting. sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
3 March 2026Gas (Economic Regulation) Bill 2026 sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
24 February 2026Gas (Economic Regulation) Bill 2026 sourceAgainstLost, 2 to 22
24 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 12 to 8
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 16 to 5
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 13 to 8
10 February 2026Period Products (Free Provision) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 4 to 17
10 February 2026Questions sourceAgainstCarried, 17 to 4
3 February 2026Justice and Home Affairs (Reform and Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Justice and Home Affairs (Reform and Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 22 to 1
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
3 February 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 21 to 2
27 January 2026That the House assigns the Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 to Mr Crookall, who shall assume the role of member in charge for the remaining stages of the Bill. sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
27 January 2026Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
27 January 2026That the Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Council on the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 [PP 2025/0127] be received. sourceForCarried, 23 to 1
27 January 2026That the Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Council on the Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 [PP 2025/0127] be received. sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
27 January 2026That under Standing Orders 2.1(3) and 3.11(2) leave of the House be given to item sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 4
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 12
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 12 to 8
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 13 to 7
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 13
13 January 2026Public Records (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForLost, 8 to 12
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 14 to 6
13 January 2026Gambling Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
13 January 2026Questions sourceForCarried, 13 to 7
16 December 2025Motion sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
16 December 2025Public Records (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
16 December 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
2 December 2025Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 11
2 December 2025Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
2 December 2025Education (Amendment) Bill 2025 sourceForCarried, 21 to 3
2 December 2025Questions sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 10
25 November 2025Questions sourceAgainstCarried, 12 to 9
4 November 2025City of Douglas Bill 2025 Dr Haywood Bill read the second time. sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
4 November 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
24 June 2025Motion sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 17
24 June 2025Motion sourceAgainstLost, 5 to 18
24 June 2025Questions sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 9
24 June 2025Questions sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
10 June 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
13 May 2025Questions (resumed) sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
13 May 2025Questions (resumed) sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
13 May 2025Reproductive Rights Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
13 May 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 16 to 6
13 May 2025Questions sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 16
1 April 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 1
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 14 to 9
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceAgainstLost, 5 to 18
25 February 2025Assisted Dying Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
25 February 2025Questions sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 15
11 February 2025Motion sourceForLost, 11 to 13
11 February 2025Statute Law Revision (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) Mr Ashford Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 17
11 February 2025Statute Law Revision (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) Mr Ashford Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForLost, 6 to 18
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 3 to 21
11 February 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 5 to 19
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForCarried, 17 to 3
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForLost, 7 to 13
28 January 2025Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2023 (Explanatory Notes) Dr Haywood Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part. sourceForCarried, 16 to 3
28 January 2025Questions sourceForCarried, 15 to 5
17 December 2024Income Tax Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
17 December 2024Safe Access Zones and Protected Public Places Bill 2024 sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
17 December 2024Questions sourceForLost, 8 to 15
17 December 2024Questions sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 15
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 17
3 December 2024Treasury (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 19 to 3
26 November 2024Charities Registration and Regulation (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 18 to 4
26 November 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 21 to 1
12 November 2024Charities Registration and Regulation (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
5 November 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
29 October 2024Motion of No Confidence sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 18
22 October 2024Questions sourceForLost, 8 to 12
23 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
23 July 2024Questions sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 17
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 16
9 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 12
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 13
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Private Member’s Bill to amend the meaning of tobacco products for the purposes of the Children and Young Person’s Act 1966 and sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Private Member’s Bill to amend the meaning of tobacco products for the purposes of the Children and Young Person’s Act 1966 and sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 11
1 July 2024That leave be given to introduce a Bill to make provision about the purpose of referenda; donations, finances and campaigns in connection with referenda; the sourceForCarried, 13 to 10
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 13
1 July 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 15
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceAgainstLost, 4 to 20
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceAgainstCarried, 22 to 2
26 June 2024Motion lost sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 14
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
26 June 2024The House moved out of Committee and business was resumed. sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 15
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 12
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 16 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 5
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 13
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 8
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 8
25 June 2024Public Sector Payments Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 6 to 17
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 14
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 15
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
25 June 2024Town and Country Planning (Amendment) Bill 2024 (Explanatory Notes) sourceAgainstLost, 5 to 18
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 15
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 4 to 20
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 22 to 2
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
25 June 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 8
25 June 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 16
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 14
11 June 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 18 to 5
11 June 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 21 to 2
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 9 to 15
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 8 to 16
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForLost, 10 to 14
14 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 10 to 14
7 May 2024Leave to Introduce sourceForCarried, 20 to 4
7 May 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 15 to 9
7 May 2024Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 1 to 23
7 May 2024Questions sourceAgainstCarried, 15 to 8
30 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 9
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceAgainstLost, 12 to 12
23 April 2024Isle of Man Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 14 to 10
26 March 2024Health Services Consultative Committee sourceAgainstLost, 7 to 15
26 March 2024Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 13 to 9
26 March 2024Constitution Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 13 to 9
5 March 2024Questions sourceForCarried, 20 to 1
23 January 2024Consideration of Clauses sourceForCarried, 20 to 2
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceAgainstCarried, 13 to 11
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
19 December 2023Consideration of Clauses sourceAgainstLost, 11 to 13
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceAgainstLost, 3 to 19
19 December 2023Bill for First Reading sourceForCarried, 24 to 0
5 December 2023Bill for Second Reading sourceForCarried, 14 to 9
7 November 2023Bishop’s vote sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
7 November 2023Assisted Dying Bill: reference to Committee sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
7 November 2023Assisted Dying Bill: reference to Committee sourceForLost, 10 to 14
31 October 2023Assisted Dying Bill 2023 sourceForCarried, 17 to 7
13 June 2023Bills for First Reading sourceForCarried, 19 to 4
14 March 2023Standing Orders Committee of the House of Keys sourceForCarried, 23 to 0
24 May 2022Leave to Introduce sourceForCarried, 22 to 2
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 13 to 11
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 16 to 8
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
10 May 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 18 to 6
3 May 2022Bills for First Reading sourceForCarried, 21 to 3
5 April 2022Questions sourceForLost, 6 to 15
8 February 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 20 to 3
8 February 2022Chaplaincy and Prayers sourceForCarried, 17 to 6
19 October 2021NOMINATION OF CHIEF MINISTER sourceAgainstCarried, 21 to 3

How this record is built, and what it leaves out, is on the methodology page.