Jersey States Member Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE STATES OF JERSEY

Visit the Guernsey edition →
04 SeptStamp duty on buy-to-let and second homes regraded from Mixed to Kept after the vote that delivered it was found unlinked; Long-Term Care cap ruling stands, with the December 2025 vote added.— Stephen Ahier04 SeptSustainable finance promise regraded from No recorded vote to Kept after a reader challenge found the amendment that delivered it, which she lodged herself, unlinked.— Hilary Jeune04 SeptTwo further verdict-based promises revised after reader challenges: constituency surgeries regraded Partial to Delivered; Equalities Minister regraded Outstanding to In progress.— Hilary Jeune
← Leaderboard·Manifesto rating·June 2026 election manifesto
Rank 25 of 46

Hilary Louise Jeune

The manifesto presents a broad platform organised around a resilient economy, a sustainable Jersey and a fairer Jersey, covering energy, housing, environment, healthcare, education and support for vulnerable islanders. Most pledges are directional, naming a goal such as 'An Energy strategy' or 'Sustainable healthcare financing' without specifying a mechanism, timeline or funding source. The text includes substantial description of the candidate's past Assembly and parish work alongside the forward commitments. Delivery of the pledges would require Assembly support across multiple policy areas.

Read the manifesto
020406080100
0
Overall · out of 100
“Needs a second draft”

The five dimensions

Select one to jump to the reasoning behind its score.

Weighted into the overall score
55
/ 100

Ambition

Weight 15%
“A credible stretch”

The manifesto sets out a cross-portfolio programme spanning the economy, housing, energy, environment, healthcare and social care. It reaches across multiple policy areas and connects them through a framing of fairness, sustainability and resilience. The pledges are largely directional rather than transformative in scope, with no named investment envelope or structural reform package, but the breadth of coverage represents a genuine stretch across the Assembly's agenda.

32
/ 100

Tangibility

Weight 25%
“Broad commitments”

Most of the forward commitments are stated without figures, dates or named mechanisms: 'An Energy strategy', 'Sustainable healthcare financing' and 'Delivering the next Island Plan' are each identified as goals but carry no further specification of how or when they would be achieved. The energy-related work and the Island Plan reference are the most concrete anchors, but neither includes a named instrument, a timeline or a measurable outcome. The manifesto is stronger on describing past work than on specifying future steps.

58
/ 100

Realism

Weight 20%
“Needs a tailwind”

The manifesto's framing of responsible public finances and cost control is internally consistent, and the pledge to deliver the next Island Plan references an existing process. Several pledges, such as sustainable healthcare financing and online protections for young people, do not identify a revenue source, a savings measure or a named legislative vehicle, leaving the path to delivery unaddressed. The manifesto does not address potential tensions between pledges, for example between green space protection and housing delivery within the Island Plan.

45
/ 100

Deliverability

Weight 30%
“Relies on other decision-makers”

The Scorecard records Jeune as Deputy Chair and Vice Chair of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (Jersey Branch) Executive Committee. Neither of these posts is in the same subject area as the manifesto's principal themes of housing, energy, environment, healthcare or the economy. The pledges across all three thematic sections would require the support of an Assembly majority of 25 members, and several would also depend on the priorities set by other members of the Assembly.

62
/ 100

Low waffle

Weight 10%
“Reasonably specific”

The manifesto includes a substantial biographical and past-work section covering the candidate's international career, parish involvement and prior Assembly roles, alongside the forward pledges. The closing paragraph restates the broad framing of 'practical delivery, evidence-based decision-making and collaboration' without adding new specific commitments. The forward sections themselves are mostly one-line directional statements. Biographical and past-work content is included alongside forward pledges throughout.

← Back to the leaderboardRank 25 of 46 · Scored by the Jersey States Member Scorecard team