How good was each manifesto?
Every Senator, Deputy and Connétable elected in June 2026, scored 0–100 on deliverability, tangibility, realism, ambition and waffle. The ranking is the ranking: by what their own manifesto said and nothing else.
The radar plots a manifesto across all five channels, centre 0, rim 100. Choose a name to lay it over the Assembly mean and see where it is strong or thin.
- Assembly mean
Could this be delivered from a seat in the States Assembly?
Specific numbers, dates and mechanisms.
Pledges are matched to a named source of funds and a realistic timetable.
Bold vision, not more of the same.
Plain English, no padding.
- 01Victoria LiIndependent · “A respectable sketch”58
- 02Catherine Dolores CurtisReform Jersey · “A respectable sketch”55
- 03Lucy Kate Frances StephensonIndependent · “A respectable sketch”55
- 04Steve PallettIndependent · “A respectable sketch”55
- 05Lyndon John FarnhamIndependent · “A respectable sketch”54
- 06Richard Anthony Kingston HoneycombeIndependent · “A respectable sketch”52
- 07Alan MacleanIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 08Andrew Nicholas JehanIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 09Carolyn Fiona LabeyIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 10Helen Mary MilesIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 11Ian Joseph GorstIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 12Malcolm Ross FereyIndependent · “A respectable sketch”51
- 13Karen Elizabeth Shenton-StoneIndependent · “A respectable sketch”50
- 14Andrea HowellIndependent · “Needs a second draft”49
- 15Mark Anthony LabeyIndependent · “Needs a second draft”49
- 16Gerald VoisinIndependent · “Needs a second draft”48
- 17Inna GardinerIndependent · “Needs a second draft”48
- 18Max Brennan AndrewsIndependent · “Needs a second draft”48
- 19Gabriel RaimondoIndependent · “Needs a second draft”47
- 20Kirsten Francis MorelIndependent · “Needs a second draft”47
- 21Thomas Anthony ColesReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”47
- 22Chris LeckIndependent · “Needs a second draft”46
- 23Montfort TadierReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”46
- 24Carina Soares AlvesReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”45
- 25Hilary Louise JeuneIndependent · “Needs a second draft”45
- 26Louise Mary Catherine DoubletIndependent · “Needs a second draft”45
- 27Chris RebindaineIndependent · “Needs a second draft”44
- 28Lee CarpenterReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”44
- 29Phil RomerilIndependent · “Needs a second draft”44
- 30Richard Percy VibertIndependent · “Needs a second draft”44
- 31Rosemary Esther BinetIndependent · “Needs a second draft”44
- 32Arlene MaltmanIndependent · “Needs a second draft”43
- 33Samantha GleaveIndependent · “Needs a second draft”43
- 34Alex Frederick CurtisIndependent · “Needs a second draft”42
- 35Sir Mark BoleatIndependent · “Needs a second draft”42
- 36Tina PalmerIndependent · “Needs a second draft”42
- 37Beatriz Borges de Sousa Vaz Moreno PoréeReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”41
- 38Lyndsay Victoria FelthamReform Jersey · “Needs a second draft”41
- 39Serena KerstenIndependent · “Needs a second draft”41
- 40Barbara WardIndependent · “Needs a second draft”40
- 41Elaine MillarIndependent · “Needs a second draft”38
- 42Mary Rose Le HegaratIndependent · “Needs a second draft”38
- 43Robert David JohnsonIndependent · “Needs a second draft”38
- 44Robert ParkerIndependent · “Needs a second draft”37
- 45Karen Margaret WilsonIndependent · “Needs a second draft”36
- 46Dave CurtisIndependent · “Needs a second draft”35
Each manifesto was read in full by the Scorecard team’s model, which assigned a 0–100 on each dimension against a published rubric. Every rationale was then checked line by line against the manifesto’s own words: a draft containing any claim the manifesto did not support was rejected and rewritten before publication.
We did not grade personalities, voting records or likeability. The rating speaks only to what the manifesto itself said. A deputy who has governed well from a weak manifesto still rates poorly here, and vice versa.
Any member can ask for their rating to be reviewed. See the corrections page for the process, and the methodology for the per-dimension rubric and bracket labels.