Jersey States Member Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE STATES OF JERSEY

Visit the Guernsey edition →
04 SeptStamp duty on buy-to-let and second homes regraded from Mixed to Kept after the vote that delivered it was found unlinked; Long-Term Care cap ruling stands, with the December 2025 vote added.— Stephen Ahier04 SeptSustainable finance promise regraded from No recorded vote to Kept after a reader challenge found the amendment that delivered it, which she lodged herself, unlinked.— Hilary Jeune04 SeptTwo further verdict-based promises revised after reader challenges: constituency surgeries regraded Partial to Delivered; Equalities Minister regraded Outstanding to In progress.— Hilary Jeune
← Leaderboard·Manifesto rating·June 2026 election manifesto
Rank 20 of 46

Kirsten Francis Morel

The manifesto sets out a cross-portfolio agenda covering economic growth and diversification, healthcare investment, environmental improvement, mental health services, education, digital public services, tourism, European trade links, data use and AI safety. The economic growth argument is positioned as the prerequisite for funding healthcare and retaining young islanders. The one forward commitment that names a policy instrument is lower alcohol duties in bars and restaurants. The past-record section names sixty new farmers and specific new flight routes. No forward commitment carries a figure, a date or a named funding source.

Read the manifesto
020406080100
0
Overall · out of 100
“Needs a second draft”

The five dimensions

Select one to jump to the reasoning behind its score.

Weighted into the overall score
62
/ 100

Ambition

Weight 15%
“A credible stretch”

The manifesto sets out commitments across economy, healthcare, environment, mental health, education, digital public services, tourism, European relations, AI safety and data improvement, constituting a broad cross-portfolio agenda. The connecting argument, that economic growth and diversification must precede investment in healthcare and opportunities for young islanders, gives the programme a degree of coherence. However, none of the commitments name an investment envelope, a reform package or a structural mechanism, keeping the overall vision at the level of aspiration rather than a named reform agenda.

33
/ 100

Tangibility

Weight 25%
“Broad commitments”

The forward commitments are almost entirely directional or aspirational, offering no figures, dates or named mechanisms. The past-record passages name specific items, including sixty new farmers and named flight routes to Paris, Amsterdam, Dublin and Bordeaux, but these describe past activity rather than forward pledges. The one forward commitment that approaches specificity is lower alcohol duties in bars and restaurants, which names the policy instrument but provides no figure, date or legislative route.

55
/ 100

Realism

Weight 20%
“Needs a tailwind”

The manifesto links healthcare investment to prior economic growth and diversification, and the tourism pledge on alcohol duties is a recognisable policy lever. However, no forward commitment identifies a revenue source, a saving or a spending envelope to support delivery. The breadth of the agenda across at least ten policy areas, without any indication of prioritisation or resource allocation, makes it difficult to assess whether the overall programme is internally consistent.

52
/ 100

Deliverability

Weight 30%
“Needs an Assembly majority and a willing Council of Ministers”

The Scorecard records Kirsten Morel as Assistant Minister for the Environment from 2026-07-07, as well as membership of the Privileges and Procedures Committee and the Bailiff's Consultative Panel. The environment and oil-dependence reduction pledges sit in the same subject area as that post. The remaining pledges, covering economy, healthcare, mental health, education, digital public services, tourism, European relations, data and AI safety, would each require Assembly support, meaning a majority of 25 of 49 members, and in several cases would depend on action across multiple policy areas.

72
/ 100

Low waffle

Weight 10%
“General in places”

A substantial portion of the text consists of general statements of values and intent, including passages on Jersey as 'an island of opportunity', the importance of heritage and the candidate's personal commitment to acting with resilience and decisiveness. The forward commitments are listed in brief bullet-point form with little elaboration, and the closing lines appeal to working together and building a shared future without adding specific content. The result is a text in which much of the space carries sentiment rather than commitment.

← Back to the leaderboardRank 20 of 46 · Scored by the Jersey States Member Scorecard team