Jersey States Member Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE STATES OF JERSEY

Visit the Guernsey edition →
04 SeptStamp duty on buy-to-let and second homes regraded from Mixed to Kept after the vote that delivered it was found unlinked; Long-Term Care cap ruling stands, with the December 2025 vote added.— Stephen Ahier04 SeptSustainable finance promise regraded from No recorded vote to Kept after a reader challenge found the amendment that delivered it, which she lodged herself, unlinked.— Hilary Jeune04 SeptTwo further verdict-based promises revised after reader challenges: constituency surgeries regraded Partial to Delivered; Equalities Minister regraded Outstanding to In progress.— Hilary Jeune
← Leaderboard·Manifesto rating·June 2026 election manifesto
Rank 1 of 46

Victoria Li

The manifesto combines constituency-level pledges for St Helier North, including a School Routes Plan, quarterly construction traffic reporting and monthly drop-in surgeries, with island-wide commitments on education reform, a Social Enterprise Model with legal recognition and an asset lock, the Women's Health Strategy, a mental health waiting time standard and protection of the arts and heritage budget. It covers a wide range of policy areas across people, place and prosperity, though funding sources for spending commitments are not identified, and several pledges in housing, energy and economic diversification remain directional.

Read the manifesto
020406080100
0
Overall · out of 100
“A respectable sketch”

The five dimensions

Select one to jump to the reasoning behind its score.

Weighted into the overall score
68
/ 100

Ambition

Weight 15%
“A credible stretch”

The manifesto spans roads, education, health, housing, energy, the economy and social enterprise, connecting local constituency concerns to island-wide reform. Commitments such as an independent Education Leadership Board, a Jersey Social Enterprise Model with legal recognition and an asset lock, and delivery of the Women's Health Strategy represent a coherent cross-portfolio reach. The scope is broader than defending the current trajectory, though it stops short of a named investment envelope or a comprehensive costed reform package.

58
/ 100

Tangibility

Weight 25%
“Taking shape”

Several pledges carry specific mechanisms or quantified commitments: quarterly reporting on Overdale construction traffic, monthly drop-in surgeries with no appointments, a School Routes Plan with delivery dates, protection of 'the 1% for arts, culture and heritage', and legal recognition for a Jersey Social Enterprise Model with an asset lock. However, a number of other areas, including childcare, key-worker housing, rooftop solar, a diversified economy and Civil Service governance, are stated as directional intent without figures, dates or named mechanisms.

55
/ 100

Realism

Weight 20%
“Needs a tailwind”

The constituency-level pledges, such as the drop-in surgeries and construction traffic reporting, are operationally plausible for a single member. Island-wide commitments, including legal recognition of a Social Enterprise Model, the Education Leadership Board and the Women's Health Strategy delivery, require ministerial and Assembly-wide support that the manifesto does not account for. No funding sources or savings are identified for any spending commitment, and no acknowledgement is made of competing budgetary pressures.

55
/ 100

Deliverability

Weight 30%
“Needs an Assembly majority and a willing Council of Ministers”

The Scorecard records Li as Chair of the Children, Education and Home Affairs Scrutiny Panel and a member of the Public Accounts Committee. Pledges relating to education, SEN, the Education Leadership Board, children's health and scrutiny of public spending fall within the same subject areas as these recorded posts. The remaining pledges, covering transport, green space, housing, energy, social enterprise legislation and economic diversification, depend on other Ministers and an Assembly majority of 25 of 49 members.

45
/ 100

Low waffle

Weight 10%
“Admirably concrete”

The manifesto is written largely in short, declarative phrases that name a commitment or a mechanism in each line, with relatively few extended passages of general sentiment. Some closing lines, including the observation that understanding identity is 'how a small island chooses its own future' and the appeal to teamwork on the bigger picture, are values statements rather than commitments. Overall the text leans toward the specific, though a portion of the island-wide section under PLACE and PROSPERITY remains directional.

← Back to the leaderboardRank 1 of 46 · Scored by the Jersey States Member Scorecard team