← Leaderboard·Manifesto rating·June 2025 election manifesto
Forward GuernseyRank 7 of 39

Rhona Humphreys

The manifesto sets out a case for collaborative political action through the Forward Guernsey group and explicitly directs readers to that group's joint document for detailed policy. The individual commitments include a three-month capital programme review, a 'Welcome Home' relocation package for returning islanders entering public services, a corporate tax proposal to move to zero/fifteen in coordination with Jersey, and directional pledges across connectivity, healthcare staffing, education, green skills, and population management. Most pledges carry no figure, date, or named mechanism, and no revenue source is named for spending proposals. The manifesto acknowledges that the Forward Guernsey group will not hold a States majority.

How the party counts
Own
41
Party
57
Overall
57

+16 from the party. The party’s manifesto rates higher than the member’s own, so the member takes the party’s rating as a minimum.

Read the manifesto
020406080100
0
Overall · out of 100
“Needs a second draft”

The five dimensions

Select one to jump to the reasoning behind its score.

Weighted into the overall score
42
/ 100

Ambition

Weight 15%
“The art of the possible”

The manifesto frames Guernsey as being 'on the edge of a dangerous precipice' and calls for 'key, brave, bold and forward-looking changes', but the substantive policy programme is largely delegated to the Forward Guernsey group manifesto rather than set out here. The areas touched on, including connectivity, housing affordability for young islanders, healthcare staffing, and corporate tax reform, span several policy domains, but the individual manifesto does not develop a coherent reform package of its own. The reach is broader than a single-issue platform yet falls short of a named investment programme or cross-committee agenda.

35
/ 100

Tangibility

Weight 25%
“Broad commitments”

The most specific commitments are a three-month timeframe for reviewing and prioritising the States capital programme, a 'Welcome Home' relocation package equal to that offered to non-locals, a commitment to vote in line with the Forward Guernsey manifesto, and a directional proposal to raise the zero/ten corporate tax rate to zero/fifteen in coordination with Jersey. The remaining pledges, covering connectivity, green skills, pastoral staffing, prescription costs, and population management, are stated as directions without figures, dates, or named mechanisms. The bulk of the policy detail is explicitly referenced as residing in the Forward Guernsey group manifesto rather than in this document.

48
/ 100

Realism

Weight 20%
“Needs a tailwind”

The manifesto states that the Forward Guernsey group will not hold a States majority, and acknowledges that delivery will require engaging in debate and building support across the Assembly, which reflects Guernsey's governance reality. The three-month capital programme review is a procedurally credible step. The corporate tax proposal to move to zero/fifteen in coordination with Jersey is directional and no revenue figure or legislative timeline is named for it. Several spending-side pledges, including investment in pastoral staff, relocation packages, and connectivity, carry no named revenue source or saving. No revenue figure is provided for any pledge.

44
/ 100

Deliverability

Weight 30%
“Relies on other decision-makers”

The Scorecard records committee roles on the Committee for Economic Development and the Committee for Housing, which places the candidate in subject areas relevant to the connectivity, corporate tax, and housing affordability pledges. The capital programme review and the corporate tax reform would require engagement with other committees and a States majority, and the corporate tax proposal also depends on coordination with Jersey. Most of the remaining pledges fall outside the subject areas of the recorded roles and depend on other committees and majority support in the Assembly.

72
/ 100

Low waffle

Weight 10%
“General in places”

A substantial portion of the manifesto text is composed of statements of personal values, descriptions of the candidate's background, and general declarations of intent such as the commitment to 'tirelessly work together with others' and to be 'true to our words'. The explanation of why the candidate joined Forward Guernsey occupies several paragraphs without adding policy content. The closing section appeals to voters with motivating language about young islanders and the island's future rather than specific commitments. Specific policy content is present but occupies a minority of the total text.

← Back to the leaderboardRank 7 of 39 · Scored by the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard team

Stay up to date

Every promise. Every vote. In your feed.

Join the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard group for new data, corrections and analysis as the States term unfolds.

Join the Facebook groupPublic group · free · no advertising