Guernsey Deputy Scorecard

AN INDEPENDENT RECORD OF EVERY PROMISE MADE IN THE STATES OF GUERNSEY

Have your say on the pledge reviews

Each week we check deputies’ votes against what they promised. Get the week’s reviews by email every Monday. Mark each one Kept, Mixed or Broken and tell us why.

Your vote will inform our thinking. We read every view and comment before we decide.

We will email you a link to confirm. Nothing is sent until you press it.

Join the Facebook groupVisit the Jersey edition →Visit the Isle of Man edition →

Guernsey · Charter

Our charter

The scorecard asks deputies to keep their promises, so we publish ours. These are the commitments we make to every deputy and every reader. The detail behind each one is in the methodology, the FAQs and the corrections log.

About

The scorecard exists to make the public record usable. Votes, attendance, promises and speeches are all published somewhere, but nobody has time to assemble them. We do that work and present it in one place, in the same way for every deputy.

We built it to help deputies as much as to hold them to account. A deputy who keeps their word has no easy way to show voters that they did. The scorecard gives them one: a sourced record of promises made and kept, with their achievements beside it and a right of reply on every verdict. Where we get something wrong, they can tell us, and we correct it in public.

We take no view on whether a policy is right. We check that deputies adhere to the reasons voters chose them, and we do it for everyone by the same method. That is how trust in politicians gets earned, and how disagreement can rest on facts that any islander can check. We also want more people to vote and to follow what happens between elections.

Mission

The scorecard gives deputies a fair, sourced record of keeping their word, and gives islanders a way to check it.

Our commitments

  1. We take no money for it

    No deputy, party, States committee or campaign funds the scorecard. Nobody pays to appear on it, and nobody pays to have an entry changed. It has no connection to any of our clients, past or present. If any of that ever changes, we will say so on this page before it takes effect.

  2. We work only from the public record

    Every verdict, figure and quote traces to something already published: the States’ voting record, Hansard, committee minutes, gov.gg, the manifestos deputies put to voters, or a named news report. Each one is shown with its source. Nobody is scored on a leak or an off-the-record conversation. Where there are gaps in the public record, we will update verdicts if further verified information becomes known.

  3. The same rules for every deputy

    All 38 deputies and both Alderney Representatives are measured by one published method. When we change the method, the change applies to everyone at once and the corrections log records it.

  4. We judge consistency, not politics

    A verdict says whether a vote matched a promise made by a deputy, committee, or party. Promises include manifesto commitments, official committee statements, and previous votes (such as voting for overall spending cuts before supporting budget increases). It says nothing about whether the policy was right. A promise counts as kept when the deputy voted to deliver it, whether or not the motion passed. We do not endorse candidates or parties, and we will not tell anyone how to vote.

  5. Only a vote that tests the promise counts

    Procedural motions do not score, and neither does tabling an amendment that never reaches a vote. A vote that bears only loosely on a promise is shown for context and labelled as not counting. Where no vote has yet tested a promise, it is marked No recorded vote rather than forced into a verdict.

  6. A right of reply on every verdict

    Any deputy or committee can add a response beside any verdict on their own page. We publish it verbatim and never summarise it. A deputy or committee representative who would rather talk it through can ask for a call, and we will ring.

  7. We correct mistakes in public

    Anyone can challenge a ruling from the deputy’s page by citing the source that shows it is wrong. Every challenge is logged and reviewed, and the outcome is published whether we upheld it or not. Every correction is named and dated on the corrections log, and pinned in the data so the weekly automated re-run cannot quietly undo it.

  8. Rulings change for evidence, not pressure

    A ruling moves when the record shows it is wrong. It does not move because a deputy, a party or a reader objects to it, and it does not move because someone knows us.

  9. We record the work as well as the shortfalls

    Each deputy’s page carries their notable achievements and media coverage alongside the scorecard. The Speaking Activity page sets out the arguments made in each major debate, with verified quotes from both sides.

  10. We will keep it running for the whole term

    The record continues sitting by sitting until the next general election in 2029, so every deputy is judged on the full term and not on a snapshot taken early in it.

If we break a commitment

If you think we have broken one of these commitments, use the “Report a profile issue” button on any deputy’s page, or reply to any email we have sent you, and say which one. We will answer.

Version 1, October 2026. If we change a commitment, the earlier wording stays on this page with the date it changed.

Storyboard

What Guernsey said

Four years of public comment on local politics, in eleven events

Open the storyboard

Stay up to date

Every promise. Every vote. In your feed.

Join the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard group for new data, corrections and analysis as the States term unfolds.

Join the Facebook groupPublic group · free · no advertising