← Leaderboard·Manifesto rating·June 2025 election manifesto
Forward GuernseyRank 8 of 39

Tom Rylatt

The manifesto is built around a six-step fiscal plan and a suite of housing, governance, education, healthcare and climate commitments, most of which are shared with the Forward Guernsey group platform. Key specifics include the 'Additional Earned Allowance' saving up to £20,000 in tax before age 30, a 1% annual baseline spending reduction targeting £25 million per year by 2029, a three-month capital programme review, a 30% planning covenant discount for intermediate affordable housing, and a move to a zero/fifteen corporate tax rate in collaboration with Jersey. Broader pledges on rental incentives, connectivity, green skills and healthcare staffing are stated without costings or mechanisms.

How the party counts
Own
55
Party
57
Overall
57

+2 from the party. The party’s manifesto rates higher than the member’s own, so the member takes the party’s rating as a minimum.

Read the manifesto
020406080100
0
Overall · out of 100
“A respectable sketch”

The five dimensions

Select one to jump to the reasoning behind its score.

Weighted into the overall score
68
/ 100

Ambition

Weight 15%
“A credible stretch”

The manifesto spans housing, tax reform, governance, healthcare, education, climate and economic development, framed around a six-step fiscal plan that includes corporate tax changes, a named spending reduction target, and a new tax allowance for under-30s. The cross-cutting programme, built around a group platform described as 'the most ambitious vision and detailed manifesto ever prepared ahead of an election in Guernsey', reaches well beyond a single theme. The ambition is real, though much of it is expressed as support for shared Forward Guernsey positions rather than as individually driven commitments.

62
/ 100

Tangibility

Weight 25%
“Taking shape”

Several pledges carry specific figures: the 'Additional Earned Allowance' saves up to £20,000 in tax on the first £100,000 of taxable earnings before age 30; the 1% annual baseline spending reduction is stated to save £25 million per year by 2029; the capital programme review is assigned a three-month timeframe; the intermediate affordable housing category is tied to a 30% discount on market value; and the corporate tax step names zero/fifteen as the target rate. Other pledges, including those on rental market incentives, connectivity investment, green skills and healthcare staffing, are directional without figures or mechanisms.

55
/ 100

Realism

Weight 20%
“Needs a tailwind”

The six-step fiscal plan acknowledges the need for revenue measures before imposing GST, and the corporate tax step names a specific rate change, which is an internally coherent revenue position. The 1% baseline spending reduction producing £25 million per year by 2029 is the main quantified saving, and no revenue source or saving is named to cover the cost of the 'Additional Earned Allowance' tax relief or other new spending commitments such as the 'Welcome Home' relocation package. Relying on private investment in infrastructure and an offshore wind farm to strengthen the economy is a legitimate position but neither is costed in the manifesto.

44
/ 100

Deliverability

Weight 30%
“Relies on other decision-makers”

The Scorecard records Rylatt as a Member of the Committee for Employment and Social Security. The pledges relating to employment, social security, population management linked to skills gaps, the 'Welcome Home' relocation package, and the Mental Health Champion are in areas adjacent to that recorded role. The housing, planning, tax reform, capital programme, education, healthcare, climate, and governance pledges depend on other committees and a States majority of 20 of 38. Several pledges, including raising the corporate tax rate, are also described as requiring joint action with Jersey.

52
/ 100

Low waffle

Weight 10%
“Reasonably specific”

The manifesto contains a reasonable proportion of specific commitments with named figures and timeframes, but also includes recurring general statements: phrases such as 'fresh perspective', 'deeply personal stake', 'policy is more important than personality', and the section on rebuilding trust are largely values-oriented rather than commitment-carrying. The student engagement pledge and the governance reform section mix concrete proposals with motivational framing. The overall balance tilts toward specificity in the fiscal and housing sections but is more general in the climate, healthcare and economic sections.

← Back to the leaderboardRank 8 of 39 · Scored by the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard team

Stay up to date

Every promise. Every vote. In your feed.

Join the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard group for new data, corrections and analysis as the States term unfolds.

Join the Facebook groupPublic group · free · no advertising